Best Italian Restaurants in Brewster, NY

We list 6 Italian restaurants in Brewster, NY.

Updated October 2026

Cuisines: North Indian South Indian Chinese Italian Biryani Pizza Seafood
Ambience: Fine Dining
Clear filter
Caterers Italian
Portofinos Pizza & Pasta
983 Route 22, Brewster, NY
Pizza, Italian
Bars Caterers
Aversano's Restaurant
1620 Route 22, Brewster, NY
Italian, Caterers
Caterers Family Style
Mezzaluna Due Inc
1511 Route 22, Brewster, NY
Pizza, Family Style
Caterers Italian
Pizza Place & Trattoria II
35 Main St, Brewster, NY
Pizza, Italian
Italian Pizza
Sinapi Pizzeria
1583 Route 22, Brewster, NY
Pizza, Italian
Caterers Italian
Taormina's Pizzeria-Ristorante
278 N Brewster Rd, Brewster, NY
Pizza, Italian

How many Italian restaurants are there in Brewster, NY?

6 are listed so far. None has five or more diner reviews in our data, so the list isn't ranked by rating yet.

Also explore in Brewster, NY

Chinese North Indian