Best Italian Restaurants in Cicero, NY

We list 4 Italian restaurants in Cicero, NY.

Updated October 2026

Cuisines: North Indian South Indian Chinese Italian Biryani Pizza Seafood

Ambience: Fine Dining

Clear filter

American Bar & Grills

Borio's Restaurant

8891 Mcdonnells Pkwy, Cicero, NY

Caterers Italian

Paladinos Cicero Pizza

8154 Brewerton Rd, Cicero, NY

American Italian

Sapori by Antonio

5909 State Route 31, Cicero, NY

Pizza, American

American Italian

Lakeshore Pizza

6969 Lakeshore Rd, Cicero, NY

Pizza, American

How many Italian restaurants are there in Cicero, NY?

4 are listed so far. None has five or more diner reviews in our data, so the list isn't ranked by rating yet.