Best Italian Restaurants in Elizabeth, NJ

We list 21 Italian restaurants in Elizabeth, NJ.

Updated October 2026

Cuisines: North Indian South Indian Chinese Italian Biryani Pizza Seafood

Ambience: Fine Dining

Clear filter

Family Style Fast

651 Kapkowski Rd, Elizabeth, NJ

Bars Cocktail Lounges

17 Broad St, Elizabeth, NJ

Cocktail Lounges, Bars

Caterers Italian

Tommy's Pizzeria & Restaurant

1063 Fairmount Ave, Elizabeth, NJ

Caterers Delicatessens

Barone's Italian Food Market

615 3rd Ave, Elizabeth, NJ

Italian, Delicatessens

5 Broad St Ste B, Elizabeth, NJ

American Italian

Breeney's Fried Chicken

1033 N Broad St, Elizabeth, NJ

Pizza, American

American Caterers

Eli's Pizza Pasta

871 Elizabeth Ave, Elizabeth, NJ

Pizza, Caterers

Caterers Italian

Jerusalem Pizza

150 Elmora Ave Ste B, Elizabeth, NJ

Caterers Italian

John's Cafe & Pizza

574 2nd Ave, Elizabeth, NJ

Italian Mediterranean

1000 Spring St, Elizabeth, NJ

Italian, Mediterranean

Caterers Italian

Michelinos Pizzeria

169 Washington Ave, Elizabeth, NJ

American Italian

Mikeys Famous Pizzaria

1000 S Elmora Ave, Elizabeth, NJ

Pizza, American

How many Italian restaurants are there in Elizabeth, NJ?

21 are listed so far. None has five or more diner reviews in our data, so the list isn't ranked by rating yet.