Best American Restaurants in Fayetteville, NY

We list 9 American restaurants in Fayetteville, NY.

Updated October 2026

Cuisines: North Indian South Indian Chinese Italian Biryani Pizza Seafood

Ambience: Fine Dining

Clear filter

American Bar & Grills

600 Towne Dr Lot 16, Fayetteville, NY

Seafood, American

American Family Style

Red Robin Gourmet Burgers

610 Towne Dr, Fayetteville, NY

Hamburgers & Hot Dogs, American

American Banquet Halls & Reception Facilities

7206 E Genesee St, Fayetteville, NY

American, Caterers

American Seafood

6866 E Genesee St, Fayetteville, NY

American, Seafood

American Caterers

Limestone Grille

7300 E Genesee St, Fayetteville, NY

American, Caterers

American Sandwich Shops

Gino's Cheesesteak & Onion

511 E Genesee St, Fayetteville, NY

Sandwich Shops, American

American Bar & Grills

Kirby's American Restaurant

408 E Genesee St, Fayetteville, NY

American, Family Style

American Coffee Shops

530 Towne Dr, Fayetteville, NY

American, Coffee Shops

American Bar & Grills

J P Mulligan's Restaurant INC

202 W Genesee St, Fayetteville, NY

American, Bar & Grills

How many American restaurants are there in Fayetteville, NY?

9 are listed so far. None has five or more diner reviews in our data, so the list isn't ranked by rating yet.