Best Pizza Restaurants in Lancaster, NY

We list 7 Pizza restaurants in Lancaster, NY.

Updated October 2026

Cuisines: North Indian South Indian Chinese Italian Biryani Pizza Seafood
Ambience: Fine Dining
Clear filter
Italian Pizza
4.8
Picasso's Pizza
5413 Broadway St, Lancaster, NY
Pizza, Italian
American Bar & Grills
99 Brick Oven Bar & Grille
99 Aurora St, Lancaster, NY
Pizza, Bar & Grills
Caterers Pizza
Brando's
470 Aurora St, Lancaster, NY
Pizza, Caterers
American Pizza
The Pizza Heist
231 Aurora St, Lancaster, NY
Pizza, American
American Caterers
Two Guys Pizza
3987 Walden Ave, Lancaster, NY
Pizza, Caterers
Bar & Grills Barbecue
Boston Hotels Steak & Crab House
5555 Genesee St, Lancaster, NY
Seafood, Pizza
Italian Mediterranean
Desiderio's
5827 Broadway St, Lancaster, NY
Italian, Pizza

How many Pizza restaurants are there in Lancaster, NY?

7 are listed so far. None has five or more diner reviews in our data, so the list isn't ranked by rating yet.

Also explore in Lancaster, NY

Chinese North Indian