Best Italian Restaurants in Peoria, AZ

We list 14 Italian restaurants in Peoria, AZ.

Updated October 2026

Cuisines: North Indian South Indian Chinese Italian Biryani Pizza Seafood

Ambience: Fine Dining

Clear filter

American Caterers

8390 W Cactus Rd Ste 106, Peoria, AZ

Pizza, Caterers

Char Pizzeria Napolitana

25101 N Lake Pleasant Pkwy, Peoria, AZ

#1 Brothers Pizza

9815 W Happy Valley Rd, Peoria, AZ

Pizza, Sandwich Shops

American Caterers

20283 N Lake Pleasant Rd Ste 110, Peoria, AZ

Pizza, Caterers

Cousin Vinny Pizza & Pasta

8267 W Lake Pleasant Pkwy, Peoria, AZ

Caterers Italian

Cucina Tagliani

8349 W Bell Rd, Peoria, AZ

Caterers Italian

Twisted Italian

9940 W Happy Valley Rd Ste 1080, Peoria, AZ

Italian, Mediterranean

Caterers Italian

15703 N 83rd Ave Ste 100, Peoria, AZ

Pizza, Caterers

Bar & Grills Bars

Lakeside Bar & Grill

9980 W Happy Valley Rd Ste 1101, Peoria, AZ

Bar & Grills, Bars

American Family Style

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

7889 W Bell Rd, AZ

Italian, Family Style

8385 W Deer Valley Rd Ste 113, Peoria, AZ

Pizza, Sandwich Shops

American Family Style

7921 W Bell Rd, Peoria, AZ

Seafood, American

How many Italian restaurants are there in Peoria, AZ?

14 are listed so far. None has five or more diner reviews in our data, so the list isn't ranked by rating yet.