Best Italian Restaurants in Surprise, AZ

We list 15 Italian restaurants in Surprise, AZ.

Updated October 2026

Cuisines: North Indian South Indian Chinese Italian Biryani Pizza Seafood

Ambience: Fine Dining

Clear filter

American Caterers

Oregano's Pizza Bistro

16914 W Bell Rd, Surprise, AZ

Pizza, Caterers

Caterers Italian

#1 Brothers Pizza

16995 W Greenway Rd Ste 104, Surprise, AZ

Pizza, Sandwich Shops

American Italian

Angela's Kitchen

19900 N Remington Dr, Surprise, AZ

American, Italian

American Caterers

13980 W Bell Rd Ste 1, Surprise, AZ

Bar & Grills Family Style

Carrabba's Italian Grill

14043 W Bell Rd, Surprise, AZ

Italian, Bar & Grills

American Family Style

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

13379 W Grand Ave, AZ

Italian, American

Picazzo Gourmet Pizzas Salads & Pasta

11340 W Bell Rd, Surprise, AZ

Italian Mediterranean

Portofino Ristorante West

12851 W Bell Rd Ste 15, Surprise, AZ

Italian, Mediterranean

14545 W Grand Ave Ste 110, Surprise, AZ

Pizza, Sandwich Shops

American Family Style

13709 W Bell Rd, Surprise, AZ

Seafood, American

Bar & Grills Chinese

Surprise Food Express

15129 W Hope Dr, Surprise, AZ

Chinese, Food Delivery Service

American Bar & Grills

Tailgaters Sports Grill & Il Primo Pizza & Wings Surprise

15529 W Bell Rd, Surprise, AZ

How many Italian restaurants are there in Surprise, AZ?

15 are listed so far. None has five or more diner reviews in our data, so the list isn't ranked by rating yet.